HomeKit is not ready enough to replace traditional security systems, but it is getting closer

Cupertino, October 8, 2021

Source: iMore

An article on Appleosofie a few weeks ago he claimed that a sticker or a "Secured by HomeKit" sign, similar to those offered with the ADT and Ring security systems, might be a good idea to avoid intruders.

David Becker writes: "What those ADT signs do is let a potential intruder or criminal know that if they go and try their bad, there is a good chance they will get it easier than a house without ADT."

It would also double as a marketing opportunity for Apple to bolster its smart home ambitions. "Apart from showing that a home is protected with Apple HomeKit products, it could be a good chance for Apple to show the world that it has a system for adding security systems and related products to its Home app," adds Becker.

VPN offers: lifetime license for $ 16, monthly plans for $ 1 and more

The article was requested by Reddit u / lukelmiller's Secured by Apple HomeKit sticker, which certainly sparked some debate about HomeKit subredditing, so I wanted to ask HomeKit experts their thoughts on the current situation. a HomeKit for security.

"HomeKit is reliable, but it still doesn't have many features that make it an all-in-one solution for a security system," says YouTuber and HomeKit enthusiast Shane Whatley, whose YouTube channel covers everything from HomeKit news and updates. to product reviews, buying guides, information, automation and more. Whatley argues that because HomeKit security systems must continue to rely on native features and automation of product manufacturers and their applications, it is not a replacement for a dedicated system.

Jon Ratcliffe din HomeKit Authority agrees that HomeKit is not yet at a time when it can be considered a user's only security system. "For HomeKit and external access, you need an active internet connection, power supply and a Home hub. If any of these are not available, so is your remote access," he adds.

"I think HomeKit's ability to function as a dedicated security system is what it lacks the most."

Asked if a "Secured by Apple HomeKit" sign would be a good idea, Ratcliffe said he was "not a fan" of the idea, with Whatley saying that most people who want to steal or cause harm would probably not recognize the HomeKit. "Protected from anything, it just shows that there is a security system in place and this is just a deterrent to the 'last line of defense,'" Whatley added.

After setting up several HomeKit cameras around my house and working on HomeKit Secure Video, it became clear that the system is useful for having recordings if there should be a break-in, but offers little in terms of providing resolution. while a break-in takes place, as a traditional live monitoring system would do.

"The Abode system has several features common in traditional alarm systems, such as battery backup, cell backup, options for a monthly professional monitoring subscription," says Whatley. "Everything works great in the Abode app, but I've found a lot of issues with the alarm modes in HomeKit that work as you'd expect."

Ratcliffe adds that while the Abode system has backup systems to deal with outages, they don't help the HomeKit. Of course, HomeKit connectivity would be lost in an interruption because you need your Home hub to be online for remote access. "However, you can still access it remotely via the Abode application if the battery backup has also started with its 4G connection."

Eve Cam Homekit Secure Video

Source: Eva

So what's missing to make HomeKit a viable replacement for traditional security systems? "I would say it has to be a complete, end-to-end delivery of Apple," says Ratcliffe. "It should be similar to the HomeKit Secure Video that the device manufacturer touches. Thus, for example, Apple would create a service within the HomeKit with the option for the device manufacturer to provide a 4G data connection to keep in remote access life. "

Whatley believes that improvements are needed in both the Home app and the HomeKit capability for devices from different manufacturers to work cooperatively. "HomeKit is a powerful platform for creating robust automation," he says. "I also think Apple has done an excellent job of improving the camera's features with HomeKit Secure Video over the past two years, but I think its ability to function as a dedicated security system with alarms and sensors is the only area where is missing the most ".

"I think what's really missing are the options for natively configuring a security system in the HomeKit," adds Whatley. "One of the selling points of HomeKit is the ability to use and automate all of my smart home products together in HomeKit, regardless of brand. This does not apply to HomeKit security systems. "

For now, HomeKit security devices, such as cameras, motion sensors and smart locks, make great additions to your home, if not a complete replacement for the aging ADT system.

Those new to HomeKit security should go for an Abode kit if "traditional" features, such as monthly monitoring and cell and battery backups, are important to your list, according to Whatley. However, Aqara's independent cameras and sensors make it a "good DIY solution".

Ratcliffe agrees, recommending that simple contact sensors on windows and doors around the ground floor are an accessible starting point. A Smart HomeKit list and a Secure HomeKit camcorder are also on the list of recommendations for new users. "It's not perfect, but it's an excellent solution that I use all the time."

What do you think? Do you think HomeKit is capable of replacing your traditional security system? Tell us in the comments.

Best selling & Top trending HomeKit product in our shop at this moment

HomeKit.Blog is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc. or Apple related subsidiaries.

All images, videos and logos are the copyright of the respective rights holders, and this website does not claim ownership or copyright of the aforementioned.

All information about products mentioned on this site has been collected in good faith. However, the information relating to them, may not be 100% accurate, as we only rely on the information we are able to gather from the companies themselves or the resellers who stock these products, and therefore cannot be held responsible for any inaccuracies arising from the aforementioned sources, or any subsequent changes that are made that we have not been made aware of.

HomeKit.Blog Is A Participant In The Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, An Affiliate Advertising Program Designed To Provide A Means For Sites To Earn Advertising Fees By Advertising And Linking To Amazon Store (Amazon.com, Or Endless.com, MYHABIT.com, SmallParts.com, Or AmazonWireless.com).

The opinions expressed on this website by our contributors do not necessarily represent the views of the website owners. 

Copyright © 2022 . All rights reserved
United States