Nest Thermostat E vs. ecobee3 lite Review

Cupertino, October 15, 2019

I absolutely want to save money. That's why I initially invested in a smart thermostat. Nest thermostats save on average 10 to 12% on heating and 15% on cooling, according to an independent study. You think that sounds good? According to their website, Ecobee thermostats can save you up to 23% on heating and cooling, paying for themselves in just a few years! Of course, there are many other factors involved in choosing a smart thermostat, so which one is for you?

In this article, I explain everything you need to know about the Nest E thermostat and ecobee3 lite in terms of main similarities, major differences, designs, features, installation process and applications. Let's start!

Amazon Shop

ecobee3 lite

  • Detects moisture and proximity
  • Integrates with Amazon Alexa, Apple HomeKit, Microsoft Cortana, Google Assistant, and more.
  • $ 169
Nest Thermostat E

Get the best offer

Nest Thermostat E

  • Detects moisture, proximity, occupancy and ambient light
  • Integrates with Google Home, Amazon Alexa, etc.
  • $ 139

Key similarities between the Nest E thermostat and ecobee3 lite

First, let's talk about the similarities between the Nest E Thermostat and the Ecobee 3 Lite, to make sure we're on the same page:

  • Neither requires c-thread: Although thermostats have different compatibilities, none of them require your home to be equipped with a C-wire, which connects the thermostat to the power supply.
  • Integrations with Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa: Whether you are in Google or Amazon ecosystems, you can voice control your smart thermostat with one or the other of these options.
  • Geofencing and schedules: Both thermostats allow you to set schedules for your thermostat and connect it to your phone's GPS.

Key differences between the Nest E thermostat and ecobee3 lite

Of course, the differences between the two are probably what will most affect your buying decision:

  • Installation: While the Nest E Thermostat runs on a rechargeable battery, the ecobee3 lite is wired into your home.
  • Detection of occupancy and ambient light: Only the Nest E Thermostat can detect occupancy and ambient light, although both can sense moisture and proximity.
  • iPhone application: While the Nest app only has a 2.1 rating on the Apple Store, the ecobee app has an impressive 4.3 rating.

Nest Thermostat E vs. ecobee3 lite Design

In terms of aesthetics, I find the Nest Thermostat E much more enjoyable than the ecobee3 lite. First of all, it's a lot more minimalistI like it better, and I also like the circular shape, while the shape of ecobee3 is a strange rounded square shape. Both have color LCD screensalthough the nest is frosted to blend in with the walls. The ecobee3 screen is slightly larger than the Nest's about an inch. If you wish to be less visible with your thermostat, I would choose the Nest Thermostat E. However, if you want a touchscreen thermostat, go with the ecobee3. The Nest E Thermostat does not have a touch screen. Instead, you rotate his rim like an ordinary thermostat.

Now, an important factor to consider is the compatibility of the home with the thermostat. While the ecobee3 works with gas, oil, fuel, electric, or dual fuel heating and cooling systems, the Nest E thermostat works with 85 percent of 24-volt systems, and neither requires a c-wire. Another major difference is the installation. You will power your Nest Thermostat E via a Rechargeable battery, while the ecobee3 lite will cable in your house. Both will connect to their respective applications via Wireless, although Nest also uses Bluetooth.

Both smart thermostats are ENERGY STAR certified, which means that the Environmental Protection Agency has found them to be energy efficient. You can have up to 20 Nest thermostats in up to three homes per account, while you can have up to 16 thermostats ecobee in as many homes as you want.

That's all for design! Now let's go to the features.

Nest Thermostat E vs. ecobee3 lite Features

Now, the primary goal of a smart thermostat is to allow you to change the temperature of your home remotely via a mobile app, but there are different ways to control your Nest Thermostat E or ecobee3 lite.

smart thermostat notice
Smart thermostat times

Both offer schedules and geofencing, available for ecobee3 lite in Android and HomeKit apps. Geofencing means connecting your smart thermostat to your phone's GPS so your thermostats will automatically adjust depending on whether you're at home or not. Imagine entering a warm and comfortable home since the icy cold, but knowing that you have not lost energy in an empty house!

smart thermostat review
Intelligent Geofencing Thermostat

The schedules are quite explicit. If you have a regular routine, it makes sense to put your smart thermostats on schedules so you do not have to worry about adjusting them.

Of course, you can also vocally control your thermostats, which will take me to my next section ...

Smart platform integrations

Nest Thermostat E and integrations of the intelligent platform ecobee3 lite
Nest Thermostat E and integrations of the intelligent platform ecobee3 lite

As you can see, the Nest Thermostat E and wok ecobee3 lite with Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant, the two most popular voice assistants. Nest also has a plethora of integrations with companies such as LIFX, Wemo, Logitech, Jenn-Air- the list continues. You can synchronize your Nest Thermostat E with connected devices of these brands to automate your smart home. For example, I like my camera being disarmed as soon as my thermostat reaches a comfortable temperature, as that means I'm at home.

Ecobee3 also works with Apple HomeKit and Microsoft Cortana for voice commands, and Samsung SmartThings, Wink and IFTTT for home automation. Although the number of integrators in their smart home is greater than the Nest Thermostat, it will not be synchronized with so many connected devices.

Detection capabilities

Nest Thermostat E vs. ecobee3 Detection
Nest Thermostat E vs. ecobee3 Detection

Temperature is not the only thing these smart thermostats can detect. Although the Nest E Thermostat can sense moisture, proximity, occupancy and ambient light, lite ecobee3 can only detect moisture and proximity. Let's talk a bit more about why each capacity is important.

  • Humidity: Moisture can warm the temperature, even if it is not technically the case, so it is a good thing that both thermostats can take into account.
  • Proximity: Both thermostats feel the movement and will know if someone walks in front of them, making sure your home consumes as little energy as possible.
  • Occupation: Only the Nest E thermostat can detect occupancy as measured by the unique thermal signature of the man. Suppose you are at home but in another room or sleeping: the Nest Thermostat can adjust accordingly and can also detect if you are not at home, as opposed to being in another room
  • Ambient light: Another unique feature of the Nest E is the ability to reduce or lighten the screen depending on the amount of light in the room, which also saves energy.

Clearly, the Nest E thermostat is gaining in terms of detection capabilities, but both thermostats impress. Now, when it comes to energy savings, both offer a report of energy use you can see exactly how much your thermostat saves you. You will also be able to add multiple users at each thermostat so they can have fun too, although Nest allows only nine people to have full access while the shortcut does not have a maximum. And that's all for the features!

Nest against ecobee apps

Nest vs ecobee apps
Nest vs ecobee apps

Without a user-friendly mobile app, a smart thermostat is only an ordinary thermostat. That's why I wanted to make sure that Nest and Ecobee have great apps, for both iPhone users and Android users alike.

Both apps are where you go Control and monitor your thermostats, add multiple users, set up calendars, geo-closures and smart platform integrations, and view your energy usage reports. Although the ecobee app got very good ratings on Google Play and Apple stores, iPhone users are not as happy with the Nest app.

"This application was designed primarily for the thermostat and Nest cameras, and every time they launch a new product or additional service such as" Nest Aware, "it seems to be integrated into the app without real development."

wrote an iPhone user in a star review. Personally, I did not see huge problems with the Nest app for iPhone, but many people had problems.

Nest E Thermostat summary for ecobee3 lite

Let me now talk to the elephant in the room: cold, hard, cash. Surprisingly, the ecobee3 lite is actually $ 30 more than Nest Thermostat E at $ 169. I say shocking because Nest products are usually the most expensive. These two thermostats are below the average price of a smart thermostat, which tends to be around $ 200.

Personally, I would choose the Nest Thermostat E on ecobee3 lite for detection of occupancy and ambient light, low cost and battery installationbut the choice will really depend on what you are looking for in a smart thermostat.

I would go with the Nest E thermostat if you want to ...

  • Battery Installation: Installing the Nest E Thermostat will be a much simpler process with Nest than with Ecobee.
  • Integrations with LIFX, Wemo, Logitech, etc .: If you already have smart home products of these brands, you will enjoy synchronizing them with the Nest E thermostat.
  • Detection of occupancy and ambient light: When it comes to energy saving capabilities, the Nest Thermostat E has it all.

To learn more, read our full article Nest E Thermostat Test.

But go with ecobee3 lite if you want ...

  • Wired installation: L & # 39; s advantage? You will never have to worry about battery depletion.
  • Highly quoted iPhone application: The application ecobee has a 4.3 on the Apple store, twice as much as the Nest app for iPhone.
  • Integrations with Apple HomeKit, Microsoft Cortana, etc .: If you are in the Apple or Microsoft ecosystems, you can order ecobee3 lite using your own voice.

For more information, check out our complete review of the ecobee3.

To see more options, check out my review of Best Smart Thermostats of 2019.

Best selling & Top trending HomeKit product in our shop at this moment

HomeKit.Blog is in no way affiliated with or endorsed by Apple Inc. or Apple related subsidiaries.

All images, videos and logos are the copyright of the respective rights holders, and this website does not claim ownership or copyright of the aforementioned.

All information about products mentioned on this site has been collected in good faith. However, the information relating to them, may not be 100% accurate, as we only rely on the information we are able to gather from the companies themselves or the resellers who stock these products, and therefore cannot be held responsible for any inaccuracies arising from the aforementioned sources, or any subsequent changes that are made that we have not been made aware of.

HomeKit.Blog Is A Participant In The Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, An Affiliate Advertising Program Designed To Provide A Means For Sites To Earn Advertising Fees By Advertising And Linking To Amazon Store (Amazon.com, Or Endless.com, MYHABIT.com, SmallParts.com, Or AmazonWireless.com).

The opinions expressed on this website by our contributors do not necessarily represent the views of the website owners. 

Copyright © 2022 . All rights reserved
United States